LEONARDO da VINCI took more pride in his mathematical work in
than anything else he did.
He set out to "square the circle" and become the preeminent mathematician
of his time.
He failed at this, but we can learn from his LUNE-EASY and mis-steps.
How not to Think like
EONARDO da
INCI
Don't procrastinate. Finish all projects.
Leonardo is described by historians as an inveterate procrastinator. He
planned to write three books on mathematical subjects, but they were never
published. His notebooks were filled with ingenious inventions and machines;
most were never built or implemented. If they had been, it would have transformed
Renaissance society. When he was in a funk, he would comment: "Tell
me if anything was ever done." On his death bed he apologized to "God
and Man for leaving so much undone."
Communicate your ideas to others using standard notation.
Leonardo invented some of his own mathematical symbols and terms. Many scientists
of his time did this because number notation was not standardized until
after the invention of the printing press. This made it difficult for scientists
and mathematicians to communicate their ideas to each other. The symbols
used today for the numbers one through ten come down to us from ancient
India by way of Greece, Rome, and the Moors in medieval Spain.
"Let no one read my principles who is not a mathematician."
Leonardo also used "mirror writing" going from right to left on
the pages of his notebooks. He was left-handed so maybe this was a matter
of convenience. He started every page on the "verso" or back side
and worked over onto the front. Paper was expensive and scarce so Leonardo
scribbled on every scrap he could find. These scraps were then assembled.
Scholars have complained that Leonardo's
notebooks are a terrible jumble of drawings and writings on myriad subjects
like a continuous stream of consciousness. Two thirds of his notebooks have
never been found.
"No certainty exists where none of
the mathematical sciences can be applied."
Develop some long-term relationships.
There is something ironic about the fact that the Mona Lisa was painted
by a man with no women in his life. Leonardo da Vinci never married, and
he never had any children. Most historians agree that Leonardo was gay,
but that doesn't explain why he didn't have some long-term companions other
than a 10 year-old boy he adopted.
When he was a student, he was put on trial for lewd conduct. Perhaps
this made him very cautious and secretive in later life. But as an engineer
and scientist, was he too detached? He seems to be afraid of losing himself
in another person when he writes: "The painter must be solitary ...
For if you are alone you are completely yourself, but if you are accompanied
by a single companion, you are half yourself." Leonardo wrote about
love, but did he practice it?
"For in truth great love is born
of great knowledge of the thing loved."
Study basic math even if you are an art student.
Leonardo studied math on his own after he finished his apprenticeship as
a painter. He had trouble with arithmetic and calculating square roots in
particular. He doubted that some of the rules of arithmetic were even true.
Consequently, he turned to empirical methods for solving geometry problems.
"Study the science of art and the art of science."
For example, to find the surface area of a cone, Leonardo rolled a real
cone on a plastic surface. From that he measured the area. By experimenting
with a real tetrahedron, he determined its center of mass. He discovered
a way to create an ellipse by moving segments of a circle. Leonardo described
himself as a "disciple of experience." He simply could not "do
the math!"
Do not over-engineer your inventions.
If you tried to cook dinner in the kitchen designed by Leonardo for
Ludivico Sforza, it would probably be your last supper. Leonardo learned
the hard way not to over-engineer his designs on this project. He re-modeled
the Duke's kitchen by automating the food preparation with some mechanical
conveyor belts for moving dishes. He also built a much bigger, more powerful
stove. For safety purposes, he installed a sprinkler system overhead to
put out any kitchen fires. Leonardo then acted as the head chef on the day
of the big banquet. He brought in more than a hundred of his friends to
carve each dish as a work of art. You can guess what happened. The conveyor
belts did not work; there was total confusion in the overcrowded kitchen;
a fire broke out; the sprinkler system rained down on the food making a
colossal mess. Leonardo's project should have been a dish washer.
Avoid fads in most things but especially intellectual pursuits.
Leonardo, like many other Renaissance mathematicians, became obsessed with
the problem of squaring the circle. Artists and architects of the Renaissance
wanted to establish a rational proportional relationship between the circle
and the square. Leonardo believed that the quadrature of the circle was
the most important problem in geometry. But it turned out to be a mission
impossible.
"The quadrature of the circle by Archimedes
is well said and badly given."
Squaring the circle would require that pi, used in calculating the area
of a circle, be a precise or a "rational" number. Leonardo did
not know that pi is "irrational." The area of the circle is irrational,
too. Lambert would prove all this 250 years later in 1761! Leonardo gave
up on quadrature problems after 1510. It dashed his ambition of becoming
the greatest mathematician of the renaissance.
Don't work for the military industrial complex.
In 1483, when Leonardo is 31 years old, he is hired by the Duke of Milan
as a military engineer. Milan was the center of arms manufacture in Italy
at this time. Why did the young painter make this career switch? Maybe he
liked monkeying with machines, like guys working on their cars. He wrote
in his notebook:
"Mechanics is the paradise of the mathematical sciences."
It must have paid well because in 1502, he changed jobs and went to
work for none other than Cesare Borgia. His job description is chief architect
and military engineer. Leonardo
spends his last years working for the French Govenor, Charles d'Amboise,
and King Francis I. The King gives him a stipend for his retirement, and
he dies in 1519 at Cloux near Amboise.
"Science is the Captain, Practice the Soldier."